Lab | Log

When it Comes to Cities, What Does “World-Class” Really Mean?

A view of the Hillbrow neighborhood in Johannesburg

A view of the Hillbrow neighborhood in Johannesburg. Photo: courtesy Kounosu, used by permission under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic License

As a monsoon of icy rain greeted me this morning, heralding the end of summer in Vancouver, I sat down at my computer with a goal: to look back at urban news from the past summer and find the most important story of the season—at least in my mind. Of all the things that happened in cities this summer, which was the one I won’t ever forget?

The competition was tough. After all, a good portion of my summer was spent tied to Twitter as Detroit filed for bankruptcy. I was riveted, not because of the incident’s voyeuristic appeal, but because of what this bankruptcy could mean for the hundreds of other debt-ridden cities around America bearing the financial burden of their ’burbs.

But even in the shadow of Detroit’s misfortune, there is one story that I simply can’t get off my brain: the forced removal by the Advertising Standards Authority of South Africa (ASASA) of an advertisement proclaiming Johannesburg a “world-class African city.” The reason for this removal? A successful lawsuit by one citizen of the city proving the campaign was false advertising.

This story was not nearly as extensively reported as the Detroit meltdown, but it takes my prize for two major reasons. Firstly, it is potentially the most impressive example in recent history of a single citizen standing up to his or her city’s hollow promises—and winning.

The case came about when Joburg resident Steven Haywood launched a complaint to ASASA that the advertisement contained “blatant untruths.” As reported by the Guardian:

“Haywood challenged a radio advert that urged listeners: ‘Imagine a city where you can rest assured knowing that it is financially stable; that there is ongoing electrification of homes. A city that is saving the environment through different energy-efficient interventions. A city that continues to create new jobs despite the economic downturn. Can you imagine living in such a city? You do.’

“The advert was misleading, Haywood argued, since the city’s finances had received three consecutive qualified audits, authorities were struggling to repair roads and rubbish was often left uncollected. The unemployment rate in Johannesburg in 2012 was 24.5%, with most of its young people out of work.

“The advertising authority agreed and ruled that the commercial should be withdrawn immediately ‘in its current form.’ It ruled that the advert ‘communicates a misleading message about the overall wellbeing of the respondent.’”

But even beyond this display of citizen empowerment, the story also brought brilliantly into light the trouble of amorphous, ill-defined descriptive phrases like this—Feel Good Urbanism, as they’re deemed in the Lab’s 100 Urban Trends glossary—that are so often tossed around to promote cities. What, the story made us question, does something like “world-class” actually mean? When one begins looking into this question, it becomes clear just how problematic these kinds of descriptors really become.

If you want an example, take a look at this advertisement (included at the beginning of the news report below) from a few years ago, when Chennai decided it was time for the city to move into “world-class” status by 2026. The entire master plan? Tall buildings:

Then there’s the often-quoted Forbes article about what makes a city world-class, where several of the 10 prominent authors interviewed mention a sports stadium or winning sports team, top-of-the-line restaurants, and esthetic beauty (either people or buildings), but only one includes a housing market affordable enough that newcomers can get their foot in the door.

It seems that we often ascribe esthetic or tangible qualities to lofty terms like “world-class” before considering the values underpinning them, and how those values should best be expressed or manifested physically. Instead of saying that a world-class city needs tall glassy buildings, perhaps we should be saying that a world-class city should have housing available to all, and then decide what the best way to go about that is in each place. Maybe then we could genuinely standardize a definition to avoid such blatant abuse of such terms.

When it comes to Johannesburg, this notion was best expressed by Michael Clark, of Urban Joburg, who argued that a truly “world-class African city” would embrace the reality of its poverty and informality:

“We automatically assume the standardized notion of a “world class” city as perpetuated by the mainstream. We assume, as Edgar Pieterse writes, ‘that modern, gleaming, skyscraper-filled cities, with adequate networked infrastructures in place to support them, is the only and ineluctable way into the future.’ These cities are aesthetically pleasing cities free of ‘crime and grime,’ free of the chaos of informality and free of the poor.

“However, these assumptions of what a ‘good’ or ‘bad’ city is may be short-sighted. Poverty and informality are inescapable realities of our cities and we should be finding ways to make our cities work for all who inhabit them rather than trying to airbrush these elements out.”

A few last thoughts on this amazing story: if we were to develop a set of values that were required to be upheld by a city deemed “world-class,” what would they be? Leave your own thoughts in the comment section below. Maybe, together, we can begin to ensure that by next summer, “world-class” actually means something.

  • judith hansen

    So well said.

    My list? To have safe and well maintained play areas within easy reach of every child, to have schools that are free

    and well attended by every kid under 16, to have nice places for seniors to meet and clean water and good transportation that is affordable. To have safe streets and affordable housing that is not sub-standard. To have a market-place of ideas that can be heard…

    Th buildings, cafes, nice shops? Only the trimmings. It’s how we live together at the basic level that reflects how we take care of each other in crowded circumstances which are our cities.

    Thanks for your promoting that which is most important.

  • Caitlin Dover

    Thanks for that thoughtful comment, Judith. Agreed: our human interactions are what make our cities. And if those interactions are considerate and caring? Well, that’s what I call “world-class”!

  • mind bird solutions

    I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i…

    Br Hills | Homestay at Br Hills | Accommodation Br Hills

  • mind bird solutions

    I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i…

    Buy Online Mattress | Spring Mattress | Mattress in Delhi

  • mind bird solutions

    I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i…

    Luxury Mattress Mumbai | Luxury Mattress Delhi | Luxury Mattress Bangalore

  • mind bird solutions

    I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i…

    Luxury Mattress Bangalore | Premium Mattress Bangalore | Mattress in Bangalore

  • mind bird solutions

    Shwethagiri homestay is located on top of the
    Biligiri Rangana Betta (B.R Hills). We aim to provide the most comfortable stay
    for the tourist with all modern amenities & thus making them have a
    wonderful and memorable trip.

    Br Hills

  • mind bird solutions

    Sobha Golden
    Quadrilateral a recently launched project from Sobha Developers. Sobha Golden
    Quadrilateral is exclusively designed for salaried professional and nuclear
    families, Sobha Golden Quadrilateral project expected to spread across 82 acres
    and this township is going to be a housing option for around 6000 families with
    availability of 1 BHK and 2 BHK apartments. It is expected to be completed by
    2018-2019

    Sobha
    golden quadrilateral

  • mind bird solutions

    Pre Launch
    Salarpuria Sattva East Crest-Location,Price,reviews is
    located in the prime location of Old Madras Road, Budigere Cross Bangalore and
    enjoys good connectivity to all points of interest located in and around
    Bangalore. Project is located in an area which is very convenient for the IT
    professionals. What makes the project one of the most coveted ones is its
    excellent location linking it with all significant landmarks of Bangalore.

    Pre
    launch Salarpuria East Crest

  • mind bird solutions

    Salarpuria Sattva announces
    Pre Launch of Salarpuria Sattva East Crest, East Crest , situated at Old Madras
    Road, near Budigere Cross Bangalore . It has 2 BHK and 3 BHK apartments
    with premium specifications and world-class amenities. Salarpuria Sattva East
    Crest Bangalore has been designed by experienced and modernity driven engineers
    of elegant cadre who have created a unique master piece of apartments with
    world class amenities and high standard specifications. It has apartments that
    range into 2 BHK (1157Sqft – 1182Sqft) and 3 BHK (1404Sqft – 1530Sqft) which
    have been designed to perfection with clear-cut specifications and modernity in
    mind.

    Pre launch salarpuria east crest

  • mind bird solutions

    Pre Launch Prestige Woodland Park is
    a combination of convenience & comfort, and is located a mere 3-4 kms from
    premiere shopping areas like M.G. Road, Commercial Street and Brigade Road.
    Also, located in the vicinity are well recognized enlightening institutions
    like CMR National Public School, Clarence High School, St. Francis Xavier’s
    Girls High School, and St. Germains Boys High School. The vicinity also abounds
    with places of devotion of all faiths like the Holy Ghost Church, The Banaswadi
    Hanuman Temple and the Haji Sir Ismail Sait Mosque.

    Pre launch prestige
    Woodland Park

  • mind bird solutions

    Pre Launch Sobha Green Acres in Whitefield is
    not just ideally located in close proximity to the city’s IT corridors but is
    also located at a convenient distance from the best hospitals, centres.It is
    expected to have a total area of 10.26 million square feet and total super
    built-up area of 7.57 million square feet, set on a total land area of 81
    acres. The project will comprise of 1 & 2 BHK units with SBA ranging
    between 650 to 1,200 square feet, with over 6,000 units

    Pre launch sobha
    green acres

  • mind bird solutions

    Sobha golden quadrilateral is located in the midst of the four major
    roads in the city – the Outer Ring Road (ORR), Marathahalli road, Varthur
    road and Sarjapur road – aptly termed the ‘Golden Quadrilateral’.
    It is located in the heart of the city’s development and is one of the
    most sought after locations in the city. Pre
    Launch Sobha Green Acres is
    not just ideally located in close proximity to the city’s IT corridors but is
    also located at a convenient distance from the best hospitals, schools,
    colleges, malls and other recreation centres.

    Sobha golden
    quadrilateral

  • mind bird solutions

    Sobha Rain Forest is a innovative value homes project build by Sobha Developers
    located at Balagere, near Whitefield Bengaluru. Sobha Rain Forest is one of the biggest developments of
    Sobha pre launched in March -15. Sobha
    Rain Forest project is expected to have a total
    development area of 10.26 mn sq. ft and total SBA of 7.57 mn sq. ft, set on a
    land area of 80 acres. It is cleverly designed 6000 apartments over a land area
    of 81 acres. Sobha rain forest available housing choices right here
    feature 1BHK and 2BHK flats of different dimensions and area covered by these
    range from 650 to 1200 sq ft square respectively. Form fashionable
    flooring to modular kitchen designs, roomy balconies and high-quality
    accessories.

    sobha rain forest